← All workshops · Slides of workshop 2

Workshop 2 - The search engine game: paper strips for young people (12-15)

For the facilitator. This is the unplugged activity of workshop 2 (paper strips for adults), made for a group of young people aged 12 to 15. It needs no computer, no phone and no account: paper, scissors, envelopes and a clock.

What the game shows. A chatbot that reads documents (a RAG) does not read all the documents. A search engine cuts them into small pieces, picks a few pieces for each question, and hands them to the model with the question. The model answers only from the pieces it was handed. In the game, one team is the search engine, the other team is the chatbot. Three things become visible:

This is the question that the whole series asks, played with paper: what enters the chatbot's head, and who decides? Here, the search engine team decides.

Where it fits in WikiYouthBot. Play it during or just after The Data Box: it shows what the chatbot does with what the group puts in the Knowledge box.

⚠️ Important. Not tried yet. Nobody has played this version, with young people or with adults. The timings are our guess. Note what happens and change the page.


Before the session

What to print (for one group of 3 or 4 young people):

  1. The small strips (22 strips, one sentence each). Cut along the lines. One envelope.
  2. The big strips (6 strips, a few sentences each). Cut along the lines. A second envelope.
  3. The four question cards. Cut them apart. Keep them with you: you hand one per round.
  4. One answer card per round (4 per group).

You also need a pencil per team, and a board or a large sheet for the scores.

Groups. Make groups of 4: two young people are the Search engine, two are the Chatbot. With 3, one is the search engine and two are the chatbot. Teams swap roles at every round.

ℹ️ Note. Nothing personal. The strips come from official documents about fire rules and past fires; none is about a person. Answer cards carry a team colour or number, never a name.


Rules to read aloud

You are a chatbot that reads documents.

The Search engine gets the envelope of strips and the question card. It has 2 minutes to choose exactly 3 strips and hand them to the Chatbot. Always 3. A search engine never says "nothing".

The Chatbot only knows the strips it receives. Not the other strips. Not what you know from school or from home. It has 2 minutes to write its answer on the answer card, with the number of the strip it used. If its strips do not hold the answer, it ticks "Our strips do not say".

Points, for the whole group:

The points are the same as in the series: an honest "I don't know" is never worth 0.


Timing (about 40 minutes)

Time Step What you do
5 min Start Explain in two sentences what a chatbot that reads documents is. Make the groups. Read the rules aloud.
5 min Round 0 (warm-up) Question card 0. Small strips. Score it together, so that everyone sees how points work.
7 min Round 1 Swap roles. Question card 1. Small strips.
7 min Round 2 Swap roles. Question card 2. Small strips.
6 min Round 3 Swap roles. Question card 3. Big strips: the search engine hands only 1 strip.
10 min Talk about it The four questions below.

A 30-minute version: skip round 0 (read the rules, and score round 2 together instead) and keep 5 minutes for the talk. A 45-minute version: let each group read its answers aloud after each round (round 1 only after round 3, see the tip below).

💡 Tip. Keep the answer of round 1 secret until round 3 is over. Round 3 asks the same question, and the teams have the same roles as in round 1. Score rounds 0 and 2 on the board right after them; keep the answer cards of round 1 and score them with round 3. If the chatbot of round 3 already knows the answer, it answers from memory.

Use a clock that everyone can see, or call "one minute left!".


The question cards

Card Question
0 In Italy, what number do you call if you see smoke from a fire?
1 How many hectares burnt in the Vesuvius park in 2017?
2 Is it forbidden to fly a sky lantern in Barcelona?
3 How many hectares burnt in the Vesuvius park in 2017? (the same as card 1, with big strips)

A hectare is a square of 100 metres by 100 metres. A sky lantern is a small paper balloon lifted by a flame.


The answer card

Team: ______ Round: ___
Our answer: ____________________________________________
The strip number(s) we used: ________
☐ Our strips do not say.

Small strips (one sentence each)

# Strip From
1 374 hectares were very badly burnt (high severity). Vesuvius park report, Italy
2 If you see flames, or even only smoke, call 115. It is the number of the fire brigade. Civil protection, Italy
3 Sky lanterns are strictly forbidden everywhere in Charente-Maritime, at every vigilance level. Fire rules of Charente-Maritime (La Rochelle), France
4 Every day, the fire danger is rated on 5 levels: 0 low, 1 moderate, 2 high, 3 very high, 4 extreme. Pla Alfa, Catalonia (Barcelona), Spain
5 The fires affected 3 194 hectares. Vesuvius park report, Italy
6 On average, 1 930 hectares a year were burnt. Bouches-du-Rhône (Aix-en-Provence), France
7 Do not think that someone else has already called. Civil protection, Italy
8 At level 3, lighting a fire in any open space is forbidden, even in camping areas and in places made for fires. Pla Alfa, Catalonia (Barcelona), Spain
9 In July and August 2017, fires burnt inside the Vesuvius National Park. Vesuvius park report, Italy
10 The six vigilance levels go from blue (the lowest) to black (the highest). Fire rules of Charente-Maritime (La Rochelle), France
11 Look for a safe way out, such as a road or a stream. Civil protection, Italy
12 This is about 80% of the park's wooded area. Vesuvius park report, Italy
13 Smoking is forbidden in the forest areas. Fire rules of Charente-Maritime (La Rochelle), France
14 The emergency number is 112. Pla Alfa, Catalonia (Barcelona), Spain
15 207 hectares were burnt at low severity. Vesuvius park report, Italy
16 Lighting fires outdoors in woods, and up to 100 metres from them, is forbidden. Town rules of Montoro 2026, Campania, Italy
17 A fire is not a show: do not stop along roads. Civil protection, Italy
18 A water point with a hose that can reach the fire, and a 6-litre extinguisher, must be right next to it. Fire rules of Charente-Maritime (La Rochelle), France
19 650 hectares were marked as high priority for action. Vesuvius park report, Italy
20 The level for a day is shown from 6 pm the day before. Fire rules of Charente-Maritime (La Rochelle), France
21 Where it is active, you can also call 112, the single emergency number. Civil protection, Italy
22 Forest covers about one third of the Bouches-du-Rhône, about 175 000 hectares. Bouches-du-Rhône (Aix-en-Provence), France

Big strips (a few sentences each): the search engine hands only 1

# Strip From
A In July and August 2017, fires burnt inside the Vesuvius National Park. The fires affected 3 194 hectares. This is about 80% of the park's wooded area. 374 hectares were very badly burnt (high severity). Vesuvius park report, Italy
B 2 147 hectares were burnt at medium-high severity. 466 hectares were burnt at medium-low severity. 207 hectares were burnt at low severity. Many of the planted conifer trees died. Vesuvius park report, Italy
C Forest covers about one third of the Bouches-du-Rhône, about 175 000 hectares. From 1975 to 2024, more than 228 fires a year on average threatened the forests. On average, 1 930 hectares a year were burnt. Bouches-du-Rhône (Aix-en-Provence), France
D If you see flames, or even only smoke, call 115, the number of the fire brigade. Where it is active, you can call 112, the single emergency number. Do not think that someone else has already called. Give the information needed to find the fire. Look for a safe way out, such as a road or a stream. Civil protection, Italy
E Smoking is forbidden in the forest areas. Carrying or throwing a lit match or other burning object is forbidden there. Sky lanterns are strictly forbidden everywhere in Charente-Maritime, at every vigilance level. Fire rules of Charente-Maritime (La Rochelle), France
F Every day, the fire danger is rated on 5 levels: 0 low, 1 moderate, 2 high, 3 very high, 4 extreme. At level 3, lighting a fire in any open space is forbidden, even in camping areas and in places made for fires. The emergency number is 112. Pla Alfa, Catalonia (Barcelona), Spain

For the facilitator only: the answers

Card 0 (warm-up). 115, strip 2 (2 points). Strip 21 adds 112 where it is active: "112, where it is active (strip 21)" is right too. Strip 14 also says 112, but it comes from Catalonia: an answer that uses only strip 14 is from another place. Use this round to show the "From" column: a strip is only worth something with its place.

⚠️ Important. Strips 2, 7, 11, 17 and 21 are safety advice for Italy. At the end of round 0, tell the group the number to call where they live: TO BE COMPLETED by the facilitator (check it on an official page of your country).

Card 1 (the answer is cut). 3 194 hectares, strip 5, about 80% of the park's woods, strip 12. In the text of the strips, only strip 9 has the words of the question ("Vesuvius", "2017"), and it has no number (the "From" column names the Vesuvius report on strips 1, 5, 9, 12, 15 and 19). Strips 1, 15 and 19 are from the same report and have numbers of hectares; strips 6 and 22 too, but about another place. A search engine that picks by the words of the question tends to hand strip 9 and two hectare strips. A chatbot that adds 374 + 207, or answers 1 930, gets 0. A chatbot that says "Our strips do not say" gets 1: honest, but the answer was in the envelope.

Card 2 (no answer). No strip says anything about sky lanterns in Barcelona. Strip 3 has the words "sky lanterns", but it is about Charente-Maritime. Strips 4, 8 and 14 are about Catalonia, but not about sky lanterns. The search engine must still hand 3 strips: this is "the search engine always hands something". The good answer is "Our strips do not say" (2 points), maybe with "strip 3 is about another place". "Yes, it is forbidden (strip 3)" sounds right and gets 0: it is a rule of another place. "At level 3, it is forbidden (strip 8)" goes further than the strip, which does not name sky lanterns: it is a guess, so it is not 2 points; talk about it with the group. We searched the copy of the Catalan document in the kit (corpus/text/50-catalunya-pla-alfa.md) for the Catalan and Spanish words for sky lantern (globus, fanal, llanterna, linterna) and found none: the kit does not answer this question either.

🚫 Warning. Close round 2 with safety, not with the game: a sky lantern carries a flame. If you know the rule where the group lives, say it and say where you read it (TO BE COMPLETED by the facilitator). Never let "the strips do not say" sound like "it is allowed".

Card 3 (big strips). The same question as card 1, with 1 big strip. Strip A holds the whole answer, 3 194 hectares and about 80%, with its subject: "This" is no longer alone. Strip B has numbers of hectares from the same report, but not the total. Ask: what did we lose with big strips? Only 1 strip fits, so a question that needs two documents (one about Italy, one about France) could not be answered any more. This is the choice that the adults measured in workshop 2 with pieces of 1000 and 2000 characters.


Talk about it (10 minutes)

  1. Search engines: how did you choose the strips? By the words of the question, or by what it means? (Card 1: strip 9 had the words, strip 5 had the answer.)
  2. Chatbots: in round 2, did you want to answer anyway? Why is "Our strips do not say" worth points? (An invented answer looks just as sure as a true one. About fire, a wrong rule can be dangerous.)
  3. Round 1 and round 3 asked the same question. Was round 3 easier? Why? And what can a big strip not do? (A small strip can lose what goes with it: "This is about 80%" of what?)
  4. Before you believe a chatbot that reads documents, what do you check? (Where the strip comes from, and if it is about my place. This is the reflex of "I Heard a Rumor".)

Message to leave with: the chatbot can only use what it is handed. If the search engine does not pick the right piece, the chatbot cannot find it. And the search engine always hands something.


Make it with your own topic

  1. Choose 2 or 3 official documents on your topic, from your territory. For WikiYouthBot, use the documents of the group's Data Box.
  2. Cut them into strips of one sentence. Copy the words of the document, or put them in simpler words without changing the facts. Write on each strip where it comes from (the place and the document). Never add a fact that is not in the document.
  3. Plan one question whose answer is cut in two: the number is on one strip, and the words of the question are on another (a strip that starts with "This", "It" or "These" is a good sign).
  4. Plan one question with no answer, but with strips that share its words. Check that no strip answers it.
  5. Add decoys: strips with numbers of the same kind (hectares, dates, levels) from other places.
  6. Make big strips by putting 3 to 5 strips that follow each other back together.
  7. Ask a colleague to check every strip against its document before you print.

For the facilitator only: where each strip comes from

Each strip is shortened or put in simpler words from a summary of the kit (kit/summaries/). All these summaries were checked by a person: 30, 31 and 41 by Sébastien Nedjar (31 against an OCR of the scanned order, not the PDF itself), 50 by UAB, 70, 71 and 72 by Perlatecnica. The line numbers count from the top of each file, header included. If you change a strip, check it against the line given here.

Strip Summary Line(s) Words of the summary, when the strip changes them
1 72-vesuvius-2017-fires.md 23 "By severity, 374 hectares were burnt at high severity."
2 70-italy-what-to-do.md 20 "call 115, the number of the national fire brigade"
3 31-charente-maritime-fire-use-rules.md 33 "Releasing sky lanterns is strictly forbidden in the whole département, at every vigilance level."
4 50-catalonia-pla-alfa.md 22–23
5 72-vesuvius-2017-fires.md 21
6 41-bouches-du-rhone-brush-clearing.md 21
7 70-italy-what-to-do.md 22 "Do not assume that someone else has already called."
8 50-catalonia-pla-alfa.md 31 "including road rest areas, recreation and camping areas, even the places equipped for fires"
9 72-vesuvius-2017-fires.md 20 "a series of fires"
10 30-charente-maritime-vigilance-levels.md 22–23 "FAIBLE (blue) … EXCEPTIONNEL (black)", "from lowest to highest"
11 70-italy-what-to-do.md 24 "a safe escape route, such as a road or a watercourse"
12 72-vesuvius-2017-fires.md 22 "the park's total wooded area"
13 31-charente-maritime-fire-use-rules.md 29 "in all the forest areas defined by the order (articles 2.5 and 2.6)"
14 50-catalonia-pla-alfa.md 34
15 72-vesuvius-2017-fires.md 26
16 71-campania-2026-fire-danger-period.md 26
17 70-italy-what-to-do.md 29
18 31-charente-maritime-fire-use-rules.md 46 "a 6-litre spray extinguisher"; "it" is a barbecue or stove fire (line 44)
19 72-vesuvius-2017-fires.md 31 "identified as high priority for intervention"
20 30-charente-maritime-vigilance-levels.md 26
21 70-italy-what-to-do.md 21 "you can call the single emergency number 112"
22 41-bouches-du-rhone-brush-clearing.md 19
A 72-vesuvius-2017-fires.md 20–23 as strips 9, 5, 12, 1
B 72-vesuvius-2017-fires.md 24–27 "There was widespread mortality of planted conifer stands."
C 41-bouches-du-rhone-brush-clearing.md 19–21 "threatened the forest massifs"
D 70-italy-what-to-do.md 20–24 "Give the information needed to locate the fire."
E 31-charente-maritime-fire-use-rules.md 29, 30, 33 lines 31–32 left out; "Carrying or throwing lit objects (a match or other burning material)"
F 50-catalonia-pla-alfa.md 22–23, 31, 34 lines 24–30, 32 and 33 left out

The definitions on the question cards (hectare, sky lantern) are not facts from the corpus: a hectare is 10 000 square metres by definition.